Number One: “These are the best days/years of your life.”
This expression is often used by middle-aged or elderly people when speaking to teenagers and young adults with the idea that it encourages them to live in the moment and to enjoy the carefree days of their youth. But it’s actually a depressing and discouraging thing to tell someone because it’s basically equivalent to saying, “Things are never, ever going to get any better than they are now.” That’s a little sad even if the person hearing it really is relatively content and carefree, but the fact of the matter is that most teenagers and young adults really aren’t that happy with the way things are going. In the same way that adults tend to forget the extent of the disappointments and frustrations of childhood, it would seem that older adults forget the extent of the stresses and struggles of being younger.
School is hard, learning to make financial decisions for oneself is hard, and making long-term life choices is hard. And right now, it is becoming increasingly normal for recent college graduates to initially fail at the whole being-a-grownup thing, and to take several years to figure out how they’re going to make ends meet and what they’re going to do with their lives.
As someone who doesn’t have a home or much of any money, who has recently moved to an unfamiliar area and isn’t having an easy time settling in, who doesn’t necessarily eat three meals every day because food is expensive, and who spends a couple hours a day driving a car that has had the check engine light on for more than ten months now, I don’t want to hear that these are the best days of my life.
I do realize that there are advantages and disadvantages to every age bracket, and that being middle-aged or elderly isn’t all that great, either. I’m pretty sure that there’s no specific age that is the best age to be. Everyone goes through times that are happier or harder than other times, and the chronology of those phases varies from person to person. Even within the life of one specific individual, it would probably be impossible to pinpoint a certain time period that was the best. But the bottom line is that nobody likes being told by an oblivious but well-meaning friend or family member that they have things better than they actually do. So unless you somehow happen to be absolutely certain that someone is genuinely content with their current lot in life, you shouldn’t imply to them that it’s only downhill from there.
Number Two: “There are other people who have it worse.”
On tumblr recently, someone posted a text post that went something like this: “After much searching, the person with the worst life is finally found. They are officially granted permission to be sad, but only them, and no one else.” (Paraphrased quotation because I’m too lazy to go back and find it) As silly as that is, the absurdity comes from the implication of the original cliché, not from the tumblr user’s response to it.
After all, why would it be reassuring or comforting to point out to someone who has a problem that there are other people who have it worse? Unless the person to whom you are talking has some serious personality issues, they aren’t going to be happy about someone else’s woes. Even if someone is unselfish enough to easily and immediately forget their own difficulties in order to feel sympathy for someone else, that person is still not going to be happy about the situation. Empathy for other people’s hardships is not an enjoyable state of mind, even if it is morally better than feeling sorry for one’s self.
By an odd coincidence, nearly every time that someone I know has been seriously injured, it has occurred at a time when I was frustrated by a reoccurring minor injury myself, and it neither cheered me up nor cured my not-really-very-severe pain to know that someone else was suffering from much worse pain. It made me feel both guilty and worried at a time when I was already upset.
Besides that, it’s not as if a person can suddenly become happy just by deciding that they ought to be happy. Despite what every motivational speaker has repeatedly said, you don’t choose your emotions. They are determined in part by your personality and in part by the circumstances and events of your life. Neither of those factors is something that you can change at will; if they were, you wouldn’t ever be unhappy in the first place. When things are going badly, the last thing you need is someone trying to guilt-trip you into being happy, especially because guilt is also a negative emotion.
Number Three: “God will never give you more than you can handle.”
Like many religious clichés, this isn’t actually in the Bible, but it’s often quoted as a piece of scriptural wisdom. You can already tell from that fact alone that something’s a little fishy about it. Granted, there are some Bible verses that could technically be reworded to say this, if you were really flexible with how you defined what it means to be able to “handle” something. But that ambiguity is the only way you can get away with using this cliché. After all, stress and unhappiness can worsen physical diseases and trigger mental illnesses, people’s personalities and outlooks on life can change for the worse because of difficult experiences, and there have even been people who have lost their faith after going through a traumatic loss. If none of those things count as not being able to “handle” something, I’m not sure what would.
This is essentially a false promise, just like the false promise that God will give you financial abundance if you donate a certain amount of money to a televangelist, or that God will heal the physical infirmities of anyone whose faith is strong enough. (So therefore, anyone who is ill or injured or who has a disability must not have very strong faith.) And just like those other false promises that claim to come from God, there is risk that a person will be turned away from the church when they realize that life as a Christian really isn’t free from all cares and concerns. There are plenty of wonderful promises that God does make; there isn’t any need for people to make up their own divine promises to share with each other just because they sound good.
Of course, that isn’t to say that anyone who hears a cliché like this will be turned away from their faith. More likely, the person hearing these kinds of promises will be hurt that they’re being fed meaningless clichés when they could really use some genuine moral support. But that’s still a good reason that people just shouldn’t say things like this.
Anonymous
Sep 11, 2013 @ 19:25:30
I think that people resort to clichés because it’s often extremely difficult to articulate a message that will truly make someone feel better. Even when you know someone well, it is still hard to determine what will comfort them and what won’t. I am sorry to hear that you are having challenges in your life, but I hope that things will get better for you.
Also anonymous
Sep 12, 2013 @ 12:43:01
Regarding # 1: I remember the summer I had graduated high school and was heading off to college, and a man a few years older than my parents told me to make sure to enjoy college, because those four years would be the best in my life. I felt sorry for him that he had lived so many years that he thought weren’t as good as his college years.
Regarding # 3: I’m too lazy to look it up, but there is a verse in one of Paul’s letters that says something to the effect that God will not allow you to face more than you can bear. However, this verse is frequently misquoted; the context is temptations to sin, not grief and suffering. In other words, Paul’s point is that no one who sins can use the excuse that the temptation was irresistible. You are right to say that the Bible does not promise that God will limit one’s problems to what He knows that person can “handle” (whatever that word means).
Donna
Oct 06, 2013 @ 23:06:31
Actually, I think the Bible scripture you’re referring to is I Corinthians 10:13. It speaks of God not bringing you through trials and tribulations that no man can bear, but also that whatever you come to, He will also provide a way out. I *think* that’s the one people are usually thinking of when they use that cliche. I don’t consider myself a Christian anymore, (ironically,had that trauma in my adolescence and Christianity didn’t help any, killed me spiritually, so I left it), I’m eclectic, but my family is Christian, I was raised that way, and I respect all faiths and study a bit. As for hardships and stupid sayings, you hit the nail on the head here. Another I hate is “You don’t look sick.” 🙂 Thank you! Still hurt like hell from a degenerative spine, but I’m glad all my meds are kicked in enough and I did my hair and makeup today so you’re comfortable sitting with me without looking at me with pity, cause I hate that even more. Sigh. Some people just don’t think, they don’t have the ability to see the world through another’s eyes, through any but their own, no other perspective. It’s a shame really.
kaleidoscope49
Oct 08, 2013 @ 00:26:36
I’m sorry that you’ve been through hardships and that they have evidently pulled you away from Christianity. Not to be critical of you or your religious background in particular, but I think this is why it’s such a serious problem that we live in a society where we think that faith ought to be equated with happiness, and that religion is supposed to bring good things and fulfill emotional needs. That’s so thoroughly engrained in our culture that I think most of us believe it to some extent on the subconscious level, even if we understand that Jesus never promised that Christians would have easy lives. Verses like 1 Corinthians 10:13 and Romans 8:28 are being taken out of context when anyone tries to use them to promise an easy life for Christians. When one reads them together with the surrounding passages, it’s clear that they are not talking about earthly blessings and deliverance, but about the salvation and eternal life that has already been given to us. Sometimes, when things go badly, it’s nonsensical and unhelpful to try to view it as a blessing in disguise or to look for God’s hand in every disappointment or disaster. Sometimes, it’s better just to acknowledge that this world is messed up and that terrible things happen a lot. Christianity isn’t supposed to be a cure for life’s problems; it’s a guarantee that there’s something better and that God is so gracious that he’s giving it to us. Again, I don’t mind to criticize you, but I think you’re a victim of a mindset that has worked itself into Christianity despite being an unChristian idea.
Donna
Oct 07, 2013 @ 18:32:37
OMG i just scrolled through again! I usually get denied for all sorts of assistance, but I read the caption under the application. I qualify! Yay! I can be sad! 🙂 I’m telling you, if it weren’t for snark and sarcasm, I’d have nothing! Thanks for encouraging my nerdly warped sense of humor 🙂 I love your blog.
kaleidoscope49
Oct 08, 2013 @ 00:20:56
Thanks, glad you like it!
Eric Rachut
Apr 02, 2021 @ 09:57:13
When I was about ten, my father told me to enjoy my childhood, that it was better than being an adult. After thinking about how tough I had it (having to be at my desk when the bell rang; tests; bullies), I asked him why and he said, after long thought, because I didn’t have to pay taxes. I resolved then never to forget about how hard it is to be a kid.